Insurance Nerds - Insuring Tomorrow

#1 Insurance Adjuster Shortage: The Fossil Workforce Is Tapped. Who Replaces Them?

Written by Chris Stanley | Nov 19, 2026, 5:59:54 PM

There is a shortage of insurance adjusters.

A quarter of them will retire by the end of 2027. The industry still has 21,600 openings to fill every year. Yet entry-level adjuster postings are down nearly 50%, while senior postings sit 80% above 2017 levels.

We want veterans. We stopped making them.

Most people see shrinking claims jobs and assume AI is taking them. I see an industry leaning on AI and a few veterans because it can’t find enough qualified people, and a hiring playbook built for a workforce that no longer exists.

Is There an Insurance Adjuster Shortage?

Yes, and employers feel it. 72% of insurers say labor shortages affect their ability to grow and manage claims, and 24% rank talent as their number one challenge. Claims is one of insurers’ most in-demand areas, right behind technology.

Yet thousands of people want these roles. IA Path alone has trained more than 5,500 of them. Many get skipped for interviews, applying to hundreds of firms while their resumes get shoved in a box.

How is that possible?

For decades, our industry has hired from one talent pool: the Fossil Workforce.

Why the Adjuster Shortage Is Getting Worse: The Fossil Workforce Is Retiring

The Fossil Workforce is the cream of the crop. People like me, who were trained and mentored on the job. They were forged through time and pressure in the seat, with mentors around them, until they became liquid hiring gold. Their experience was earned. Hard won.

They’re the people who meet the 2–5 year experience requirement most job postings ask for. They have the intuition, judgment and gut to make claims decisions without a documented process or oversight.

And they’re leaving. 400,000 insurance professionals have retired since 2021. Sedgwick predicts a quarter of today’s adjusters will retire by the end of 2027. The veterans who remain are already employed.

 

The pool every job posting is drilling into is running dry.

The Other Half of the Adjuster Shortage: Claims Stopped Hiring Beginners

While experience walks out one door, we’ve locked the other. 78% of insurers are most likely to add experienced people, and only about one in five say they most need entry-level hires. By January 2025, entry-level roles were just 16% of insurers’ planned hires, the lowest the study had ever recorded.

I’ve seen what that costs.

In 2016 I was handling claims as an independent auto damage appraiser in the Denver market. I was moving back East, so I trained my replacement. He wanted a good, stable industry, and he was pumped.

I told the company he could take over and I’d mentor him, so they’d keep their coverage.

They said, “He doesn’t have enough experience.”

I offered to review his files. They still refused.

He became a manager at a coffee shop. He never came back to the industry.

That happens every week, at carriers, IA firms and collision centers. We don’t have a talent problem. We have a taste problem.

Three Hiring Habits Making the Adjuster Shortage Worse

For two decades we’ve been spoiled by experienced adjusters, estimators and appraisers.

Veterans were plug and play, so many companies forgot how to develop new talent. Covid made it worse. Many carriers and firms shut down their development programs, and from what I see, most are still closed.

Instead, we fell into three habits that is causing leakage in our existing talent pipeline:

  1. Post and Poach: Post a job, and if no one with experience applies, steal someone from another company. We’re not adding talent. We’re just swapping it.
  2. Bench and Burn: We won’t promote our own people because we need them where they are, so we poach from outside for the higher role. Our people get frustrated and leave the company, or the industry.
  3. Deploy and Destroy: When we get truly desperate, we send a new person out without real training or mentorship, hand them a veteran’s workload and say “sink or swim.” In my conversations with 50+ IA firms, only about 25% of people on their first catastrophe deployment last more than a week. And replacing an experienced adjuster costs 50–200% of their salary. We’re lighting our talent pool on fire and wondering where it went.

We can’t make more of the Fossil Workforce. It would take too long. So who should we hire?

Who Replaces Retiring Adjusters? Hire the Right Human in the Room

Stop hiring for the right resume. Hire the right Human in the Room. They have three traits.

Interested. They want the industry, the role and your mission. Plenty of long-timers do this job only because it’s what they’ve always done. Someone genuinely interested sticks around, and they’re a breath of fresh air to everyone around them.

Invested. They paid for their own adjuster license and training before anyone asked. They have skin in the game and will fight to make it work, unlike the employee who waits to be trained.

Intelligent. They can read a room, and that takes three kinds of intelligence:

  • Practical: they can assess the damaged car in the room and learn the process to handle it.
  • Emotional: they understand what the owner is feeling.
  • Social: they can navigate the relationships between shops, carriers and owners.

Someone with all three is the right Human in the Room.

As AI becomes more a part of the insurance industry, having the correct Humans in the Room will be the difference between the companies that thrive and those that merely survive.

At IA Path we’ve trained more than 5,500 appraisers, adjusters and estimators over the past 10 years. They’re nurses, homeschool moms, insurance agents, waiters, police officers and high school graduates. We’ve yet to find someone interested and invested who couldn’t become a contributing member of a firm, carrier or shop.

We don’t have to wait years to fix the talent shortage. We just have to change our taste.

If you have a talent pipeline problem, I’d love to help you tap into the Renewable Workforce. Talk to IA Path

Next week: how to get new adjusters to make decisions like a veteran in a couple weeks.