2 min read

Eight Errors of Thinking That Quietly Drain Insurance Careers

Eight Errors of Thinking That Quietly Drain Insurance Careers

"Whoever wishes to increase human happiness must wish to increase admiration." Bertrand Russell, The Conquest of Happiness

Bertrand Russell argued in The Conquest of Happiness that unhappiness is "very largely due to mistaken views of the world, mistaken ethics, mistaken habits of life." Arthur C. Brooks recently revisited that argument in The Atlantic, in a column titled "Eight Ways to Banish Misery." Russell was a mathematician and logician, and he treated unhappiness the way a good analyst treats any messy problem: break it into parts and fix each one. That approach will feel familiar to anyone in insurance.

Our industry is built on managing negative outcomes. We price them, transfer them and reserve for them. Yet many of us manage our own professional unhappiness with far less discipline. Russell's eight errors are a useful checklist.

The first is fashionable pessimism. Insurance professionals are trained to look for what can go wrong, and that habit can harden into a pose where skepticism is mistaken for sophistication. Russell considered this pose a conceit. Brooks notes that pessimism also distorts perception, which makes it a poor tool for a profession that depends on accurate judgment.

The second and third are social comparison and envy. Rankings, league tables, production reports and bonus pools invite constant comparison. Russell observed that people fear less that they will fall into poverty than that they will fail to outshine their neighbors. His remedy for envy is to increase admiration. Look at the colleague or competitor who excels at something you want to do well, and study that person instead of resenting them.

The fourth is evading boredom. Much of this industry is detailed, repetitive work: submissions, endorsements, bordereaux, claim files. Russell wrote that we are less bored than our ancestors but more afraid of boredom, so we reach for distraction. Brooks points to the practice of noticing. Attention to the file in front of you is where errors are caught and where interesting patterns show up.

The fifth is coping with fear. Russell's advice is to name the fear and think about it calmly and with great concentration until it becomes familiar. Insurance professionals already do this for clients, through scenario analysis and stress tests. Apply the same method to a career concern, such as a renewal at risk or a regulatory change, and familiarity does the rest.

The sixth is senseless guilt. Claims professionals who deny a claim that the policy language requires them to deny, or underwriters who decline a risk that fails guidelines, can carry guilt for decisions that were correct. Brooks suggests gratitude as a practical remedy, and notes that it works even when practiced without feeling it first.

The seventh is virtuous victimhood. Every organization has its share of grievance: the broker who was undercut, the underwriter who was overruled, the claims team that was blamed. Some of it is justified, and Brooks is clear that real injustice should be named. The risk is building an identity around it. Research links prolonged self-pity to anger and depression, and it rarely improves the outcome.

The eighth is fear of public opinion. Russell advised respecting opinion only as far as needed to avoid starvation and prison. In our terms, that means regulatory and contractual obligations. Beyond those, deferring to what peers, committees or the market might think becomes, in his words, "an unnecessary tyranny." Brooks notes that social pain is real, and that conscious reasoning is the tool that helps.

The lesson for the industry is practical. Wellbeing is not a perk or a soft topic. It affects judgment, retention and the quality of the decisions we make about other people's risk. Russell's method is to diagnose before treating. Pick the one error on this list that you recognize most readily in yourself or in your team, and address that first.

This article is part of our Happiness series, inspired by Arthur C. Brooks and his Atlantic column. Read the original, Eight Ways to Banish Misery, in The Atlantic.

Why Insurance Professionals Should Say What They Actually Think

2 min read

Why Insurance Professionals Should Say What They Actually Think

"Whoso would be a man must be a nonconformist." Ralph Waldo Emerson, Self-Reliance Insurance runs on judgment shared across many people....

Read More
The Case for Courtesy in Insurance

2 min read

The Case for Courtesy in Insurance

"Life is not so short but that there is always time enough for courtesy." Ralph Waldo Emerson Insurance runs on relationships and on written words....

Read More
The Insurance Case for a Personal Well-Being Protocol

2 min read

The Insurance Case for a Personal Well-Being Protocol

"Amateurs sit and wait for inspiration, the rest of us just get up and go to work." Stephen King said that about writing, but it applies just as well...

Read More